Can Sustainable Fashion Be Affordable? We Checked Vogue's Top Aussie Brands to See if It's Possible.

Okay, let's be real. That question: " can sustainable fashion be affordable?" It’s the one we all wrestle with, right? You’re scrolling, you find something from an Aussie label, the price tag isn't a total heart-stopper... but that little voice kicks in. "Is this... okay?"

That's the dilemma. This constant pull between wanting sustainable fashion and, well, having a budget. We all want clothes that don’t wreck the environment, but the fashion industry keeps serving up ethical fashion with a higher price tag. And that leaves you... stuck. You want eco friendly clothing and sustainable clothes, but you're (rightfully) suspicious of the increased cost.

Is affordable sustainable fashion just a marketing myth? Can sustainable fashion affordable actually be a real thing? We see most consumers getting tangled in the true cost of clothing. And that true cost isn't just the initial cost on the tag. It’s the hidden environmental impact and the shaky labor practices behind the scenes. The broader audience is waking up to the fact that low prices often mean someone, or somewhere, is paying the price. The fast fashion honeymoon is over.

The Big Question Everyone Is Asking

So, we decided to dig into it. Do sustainable fashion affordable options actually exist where real people shop? We took Vogue Australia's recent "affordable" fashion brands list as our guinea pig. We ran these popular clothing brands and fashion companies through our sustainability checker.

And what we found about affordable sustainable fashion in Australia? It’s... complicated. The reality of embracing sustainable fashion at low prices isn’t a simple yes or no. It’s a messy, nuanced issue that the broader audience really needs to get.

"It's a Start" is the New Normal

Here’s the most interesting thing we found: the most common rating wasn't "Great." Or even "Good." It was "It's a Start."

This wasn't just one or two brands. It was the norm. Big names, including sustainable fashion brands (or those trying to be) like Nobody Denim, Deiji Studios, and Assembly Label, all landed here.

And honestly? In the wild west of the fashion industry, "It's a Start" is actually pretty encouraging.

What does that mean? It means these sustainable brands are on the journey. They're actually implementing some sustainable practices. They're trying to break up with the toxic fast fashion model. Take Deiji Studios. They snagged a "Good" rating for Planet (68/100) because they use organic cotton and actively recycle their textile waste offcuts. That’s a solid effort. 

Or Nobody Denim. They score great on "Animals" (a very high 84/100), trace most of their supply chain, and use proper certifications like SMETA and SA8000 for ethical production. That's real work. 

Even Assembly Label gets an "It's a Start" for Planet by using a "medium proportion" of eco friendly materials and powering their stores with renewable energy. This is a shift to eco friendly materials and away from the "wear it once" vibe of fast fashion brands – a massive, positive step for fashion.

The "But": Where is the Sticking Point?

Okay, so if they're using organic cotton and recycled materials, what's the catch? Why no "Good" or "Great" sticker?

The data showed a super clear pattern. The reason? Almost always: the "People" score.

To be blunt: it boils down to a lack of proof that they pay a living wage.

This is the exact spot where low prices smash right into ethical practices. Look, ensuring fair wages and fair labor practices isn't cheap. It just isn't. It bumps up production costs because it means being transparent and accountable all the way down the supply chain. Committing to real ethical fashion and responsible production is the hardest, most expensive move a brand can make.

Let's look at the data. Nobody Denim, with all their good scores? The report says: "There’s no evidence it ensures workers are paid living wages..." Assembly Label? Same story: "There’s no evidence it ensures workers are paid living wages..." 

And Deiji Studios, despite a "Good" People score (72/100) for regular visits and a Code of Conduct? The fine print is: "It’s not clear if it ensures workers are paid living wages..."

This is the uncomfortable truth, the true cost of fashion. It forces us to ask if those low prices are only possible because garment workers are paying the difference. It's a fundamental flaw in the fashion industry that consumers are finally starting to see.

The "Not-So-Good" and the "Not-Yet-Rated"

Of course, the Vogue list wasn't all sunshine and sustainable materials. It was a mixed bag. Some popular clothing brands scored... badly.

Take Ksubi. They earned "We Avoid." Why? Not because of one single horrible score, but because of a total lack of transparency. Good On You notes they provide "insufficient information" about what they're doing for people, the planet, and animals. We can't even get a clear score for "People" or "Animals "— it's just marked "N/A" (Not Applicable). That’s a giant red flag.

And then you have the "Not Good Enough" crowd, like Ena Pelly, Shona Joy, and Rolla's. The story is depressingly similar. Ena Pelly? "No evidence" of action on hazardous chemicals, water use, or climate impact. Shona Joy and Rolla's? Same thing: "no evidence" they're ensuring a living wage or even auditing their suppliers. This is classic fast fashion brands behavior.

And then there were the ghosts. A ton of fashion companies on the list—big names like Dissh, Henne, and Elka Collective — weren't rated at all. This creates a data void. It doesn't mean they're evil, but it does mean we have zero independent data on their sustainable production claims.

What to Do When a Brand Isn’t Rated Yet

This is the tricky part, right? You find a label you love, but it's not rated. So what do you do?

1. Sleuth their website: Don't just look at the home page. Dig for a "Sustainability" or "Our Impact" page.
2. Look for receipts, not fluff: "We love the environment" is just hot air. "We use 20% GOTS-certified organic cotton and our Tier 1 suppliers are audited for fair labor practices" is data. You're looking for proof. Facts. Certifications (like Fair Trade, GOTS, B Corp). Real info on their carbon footprint or textile waste reduction.
3. ...And trust the silence: If you find nothing but vague promises? That silence is loud. Genuine sustainable brands and ethical fashion leaders want to show you their work. They know transparency is everything.

Can the Brand Become More Sustainable?

So, here's the hopeful bit. Can these "It's a Start" labels actually make sustainable fashion a real thing and stay affordable?

The honest answer: yeah, partially. But it takes work.

Some sustainable fashion moves don't have to mean a massive increased cost. Using recycled materials like recycled polyester (often from old plastic bottles) can cost about the same as new stuff. As more brands use eco friendly materials, the cost comes down. Some sustainable practices, like reducing water use, can even save them money on production costs long-term.

And industry experts are all pointing to the circular economy. This is a big idea: designing clothing items to be reused, repaired, or recycled instead of trashed. It’s the ultimate way to cut textile waste and stop draining our natural resources. We're already seeing labels like Assembly Label try this with their "Re-worn" take-back program. And timeless designs? That's sustainable. Clothing you love for years, made from higher quality materials, is the best way to fight fast fashion and the urge for constant new clothing.

But... (there's always a but) ... other things, especially fair wages, do increase costs. There's just no way around it. This might mean brands offer stuff at slightly higher price points.

The real fix has to come from two sides. One: brands have to innovate. Two: We, as consumers, have to shift our own buying behaviour. That means stop seeing low prices as the only win. It means thinking about long term benefits. That $50 top that falls apart? Or the $120 one you'll wear for a decade? The growing demand (and increased demand) for real eco friendly products is the most powerful tool we have. This higher demand from a broader audience is what shoves fashion companies forward.

Conclusion: What's the Takeaway for a Smart Shopper?

Okay, let's land this plane. Back to the big question: Can sustainable fashion be affordable?

The answer is yes, but it’s a journey, not a destination. The Vogue list proves it. A lot of affordable fashion companies are trying. They're using eco friendly materials. They're being more transparent. They're ditching the toxic fast fashion brands model. They are, slowly but surely, working for a sustainable future.

As a conscious shopper, your wallet has power. Choosing an "It's a Start" brand like Nobody Denim or Deiji Studios over a "We Avoid" brand like Ksubi is a huge, conscious move. It sends a message: "I see you. Keep going." That's how you help brands in embracing sustainable fashion.

And that is exactly why Aloto exists. We do the homework for you. We help you cut through the marketing noise, see the true cost of clothing, and find sustainable clothing brands and sustainable clothes that match your values. We make it simple to check the environmental impact, labor practices (and unsafe working conditions), and animal welfare.

Think of it this way: every dollar you spend is a vote for the kind of fashion industry you want. By backing companies that are on the path, you help drag the entire fashion world toward a sustainable future.

Check Your Favorite Brands on Aloto

‍